Molicel/NPE P42A 45A 4200mAh Flat Top 21700 Cell Review

Today I have another cell for review.  This is a Molicel/NPE 21700 LiIon cell, capable of 45A (forty five amps) continuous discharge!  

As always, click for bigger images!!!


Official Specs

Here’s a link to the official product page.

Price

These cells start at $12.99.  Volume discounts start with the third cell, and get better from there!  Buy them at [only at] LiIonwholesale.com!

Short Review

These seem like good cells, with nice performance.  My A and B cells seemed to perform ever so slightly different only high discharge.  The full capability of these cells won’t be needed in most flashlights that could use them, but using a 45A cell at lower currents just means better performance in general!  

Long Review

Package

These cells ship in a plastic flip top box.

Build Quality

The positive terminal is a 3-prong type.  

Size

Testing

I’ve tried to keep the scales similar, so over time the charts will be generally comparable.

Discharge tests

Capacity

Energy

Bounce

“Bounce back” is what the cell voltage does when the cell rests after a discharge. After heavy discharge rates, the cell voltage bounces back higher when discharge is stopped.  This corresponds to a discharge amount of less energy, and does mean that there’s energy left in the cell.  So if I selected the cell with the highest bounce back voltage (ie the cell that was discharged at the highest current), then discharged it to 2.8V at 0.2A, I’d still find that there was a lot of energy still in the cell. 

Here is why I think it so interesting about “Bounce.”  A poorly performing cell will bounce back higher after high discharges.  That’s because the IR is higher, and because the cell performs much worse under high loads.  So a good performing cell will bounce back much less because it’s much more capable of high discharge.  At high discharge on a capable cell, more of the energy makes its way out of the cell!  Hence less bounce. 

I more or less figured this out on my own, so I welcome discourse about this topic.  Until I hear it’s wrong, I propose this as a new metric for cell quality!

Charge Test

Temperature
Power, Constant

Internal Resistance

Most often (read: always), internal resistance is mentioned as a spot value.  In truth, the IR changes over time.  Due to cell age and cell heat among other things.  A graph of IR is interesting because it can show, for example, when a cell begins to “die” – at which point the remaining energy will be “harder” to extract.  This is when the IR spikes.  In the graph below, that’s around 750-800mAh.  These graphs are also useful for determining if a cell would be good for a hot-rod flashlight, for example.  

Conclusion

This is a good cell.  Low internal resistance, good temperature performance at high currents, and moderately high capacity for having such a high current capability…  


Notes

  • These cells were provided by Liionwholesale.com for review. I was not paid to write this review.
  • This content originally appeared at zeroair.org.  Please visit there for the best experience!
  • Whether or not I have a coupon for these cells, I do have a bunch of coupons!!  Have a look at my spreadsheet for those coupons. It’s possible to subscribe and get notifications when the sheet is edited!!

Author: zeroair

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *